This one is another '90s favorite that is currently going through a revival period. It seems like there's My Little Pony merchandise everywhere these days. While the new stuff is very reasonably priced, the original items are now selling at extremely high prices. Who would have thought that some colorful ponies made for little girls would end up being worth so much?
Mimic the unicorn, Greek Baby Moondancer, Sweet Scoops Mail Order Pony, Baby Princess Sparkle, Oatley, and any part of the Paradise Estate will fetch anywhere between $200 to $800. If you sell Sweet Scoops with the rare Sweet Scoops charm you could definitely net around $1,500. The most valuable of all the My Little Pony collection is Rapunzel, which has been known to sell for $1,200 or more. For collectors, they're worth every penny!