American Girl dolls weren't even cheap when they first hit the shelves back in 1986, so you can imagine how much they might be worth today. The cool thing about these beauties is that they came in a variety of looks and ethnicities, along with stories about their history. They were one of the first range of dolls that seemed to include everyone. No matter what you looked like, there was an American Girl doll for that.
As with almost every toy we've discussed, certain American Girl dolls are worth more than others due to the rarity of them. Molly, Samantha, and Felicity dolls can be sold for $1,200 to $1,500, Kristen will get you even more cash at $3,200. Though Kanani is one of the newer dolls, she still fetches prices as high as $2,500.