As you'd expect from anyone with a hard, pious paper round, St. Anthony didn't look that similar to the most popular depictions of him. Did you almost forget about the ridiculous haircuts that came with being a friar? It's one thing to meet your idols, but to see them after being recreated through CGI rendering is quite another. It would seem that he never quite had cheekbones that would cut glass and never had the Eastern European look he was so often depicted with.
Whilst St. Anthony may have not carried a halo of perfectly sculpted hair, what he did carry was a pensive glare which tells us more about his harrowing life of ups and downs than any flowery representation could have done. Well, you didn't think being part of a religious order was easy, did you?